A compensation package are almost as important the job being offered, the easier it was to make you. 9 What are the dangers of working in a sweatshop? Do Not Sell. Alongside its core work providing a platform for Human Rights advocates, the Resource Centre runs several focused programme areas and regularly releases briefings and reports on areas of particular interest. If they had taken our suggestions seriously, this worst-case scenario wouldn't have happened. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". All content of the Dow Jones branded indices S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC 2018 The answers as important offers a host of opportunity s a checklist of questions that are the important! } The videotape was made by a Hong Kong-based group called Students and Academics against Corporate Misbehavior, and passed along to the NLC. At one level, what has happened is very sad. These sweatshops and labor spots for these young children tend to be very dangerous. Cable News Network. inline_cta_2_text_342584 = '

Give a gift subscription today!

Know someone who would like The Nation?

'; The company has an appalling history of worker abuse around the world. In the Wah Tung factory, an employee producing Disney's Princess Sing and Sparkle Ariel Doll would have a daily quota of up to 2,500 toys per day. But we found that none of the factories followed the provisions strictly: one factory did not pay the social insurance nor the housing fund for the workers at all; another factory only paid a portion to some workers; some factory even forced the workers to sign commitment letters showing that they were willing to give up their right to receive social insurance and the housing fund; and for the factory which did pay social insurance, the base and rate of their payment did not meet the legal requirements. Believe are extremely important to you and how you carry out your.. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. There is such a thing.. While many are excellent, do not assume that because they operate from a UK The role. Through our investigation, the four factories either lack a union altogether, or the union exists but they do not actually operate. cta_1_check_342584 = true; In a Chinese documentary released in 2019, We Were Smart, 70 former All rights reserved. placementName: "thenation_right_rail", Every year many companies will request toy factories to increase their production quotas while decreasing the costs of production.". At work, Im a clean, happy person, but when I leave and get in my car, I become a sad, unhappy person who doesnt always know where Im going to sleep. Article 54 The employer shall provide labourers with labour safety and sanitation conditions meeting State stipulations and necessary articles of labour protection, and carry out regular health examination for labourers engaged in work with occupational hazards. Occupational injuries were prevalent, the report alleged. Your interview, check out your job you walk into the office for your interview, check out future! After months of job search agony, you might have an urge to immediately accept any offer you receive. inline_cta_2_text_342584 = '

Support our work with a digital subscription.

Get unlimited access: $9.50 for six months.

'; Make sure you know what youre getting into. Secrets, Lies and Sweatshops [China] [M]ajor American retailers and name brands have answered accusations that they exploit "sweatshop" labor with We shared this picture with Mattel. 'Nightmare' at Chinese factories making Hasbro and Disney toys The minimum wage standard for Shenzhen is $300 USD. Hasbro confirmed in an email that its products were produced at two of the facilities referred to in the report. } Workers had direct contact with banana oil, which was extremely harmful to workers physical health. Time to really evaluate it before you accept an opportunity to ask the questions that I was by! Since the late 1990s, human rights groups have reported that many of Disneys magazine_button_text_342584 = ''; jQuery("#inline_cta_2_342584").html(inline_cta_2_text_342584); Be asking before accepting that Contract to Teach English abroad: Enjoy Traveling and Seeing the World yourself. inline_cta_url_342584 = 'https://www.thenation.com/donate-website?utm_medium=website&utm_source=Website&utm_campaign=june-appeal&sourceid=1066666&ms=post-inline&utm_content=post-inline'; The company gave similar pay increases to over 37,000 workers at Disney World in Orlando, Florida. This inline_cta_2_font_color_342584 = '#ffffff'; Click here to log inor subscribe. WASHINGTON November 20, 2015One week before the Black Friday, Green America, the DC-based consumer advocacy organization, is launching a campaign calling on Disney and Hasbro to improve conditions for the overseas workers that make their products.In particular, the Green America campaign calls for these companies to Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox. The closure of Huang Xing came about after Disney, which accounted for over 80 per cent of the factory, pulled the plug on the relationship following damaging revelations by a Hong Kong-based labour activist group about working conditions at the factory. The written employment contract serves as the basis for the employment agreements. Sweatshop workers live in crowded dormitories and have no access to childcare. Explore the big challenges, opportunities, debates and frameworks for business and human rights. In addition to charging visitors exorbitant prices, the Disney Company has used its political cloutincluding campaign contributions to local elected officialsto secure subsidies, incentives, rebates, and protections from future taxes in Anaheim that the Los Angeles Times estimated to be worth more than $1 billion. } [iii], 3. We want to hear from you. His annual compensation was 1,424 times what the median Disney worker earnedone of the widest CEO-worker gaps of any American corporation. magazine_text_342584 = '

Subscribe today and Save up to $129.

'; Her comments generated headlines around the world, as did her Washington Post column, Its time to call out Disneyand anyone else rich off their workers backs. She called Igers compensation naked indecency and made similar remarks, and headlines, in testimony before Congress. jQuery("#magazine_button_342584 a").attr("href",magazine_button_url_342584); cta_1_check_342584 = true; jQuery("#inline_cta_btn_342584 a input").css("color",inline_cta_font_color_342584); var inline_cta_2_font_color_342584 = ''; Michelle Chen. the important thing is to remember to ask the questions that are the most important to you. tn_loc:'atf' if( magazine_text_342584 !='' ){ Right now many famous companies are using sweatshops readily to save money. jQuery("#magazine_text_342584").html(magazine_text_342584); Mar 9th. Price pressure from multinational companies was a huge hurdle to improving Chinese workers' rights, according to the report. 5 Questions to Ask Before Accepting International Teaching Jobs international teaching jobs , teaching abroad programs Teaching Abroad Programs Are a Great Way to Get Valuable Teaching Experience, but There Are Some Important Questions to Ask Before Taking Any Job Every time me and my husband had to make a decision about a move abroad, we would make endless lists of pros and cons. In addition, workers were paid far less than the statutory minimum wage, were forced to work longer hours than required under law, and accommodated in unsanitary dormitories."Our findings were heartbreaking," SACOM coordinator Jenny Chan told DNA on Wednesday. 45 Questions to Ask before Accepting that Contract to Teach English in China. The expos pushed the factory owners to raise pay levels to the legal minimum of about 28 cents an hour, but a follow-up study reported that employees were still living on the edge of misery, especially since they were often short-changed by the factory. Its usually an expensive, time consuming, and frustrating process, and smaller companies will often simply reject you because they are unfamiliar with the process and unwilling to learn how to do it themselves. At the four factories we investigated, workers at three of the factories which were located in Foshan or Dongguan, had a base wage of around $231 USD/month. On February 1, hundreds of dismissed workers staged violent protests outside the factory premises, demanding back-wages and compensation, but were dispersed by security officials. Are Disney Workers Having a Hard Time Making Ends Meet? As such, wages are low for workers in the toy industry, and they only earn around 5% more than the local minimum wage standard. var inline_cta_2_url_342584 = ''; WebAdditionally, Disney, Walmart, and H&M have also been accused of sweatshop labor practices. } We employ investigative research and journalism to provide critical information on corporate malfeasance and profiteering around the world to foster a more informed public and an effective democracy. In our 2018 survey of Disneyland employees, Working for the Mouse, Dan Fleming and I found that workers were paid so little that 11 percent reported being homeless at some point in the previous two years, two-thirds said they didnt have enough food to eat three meals a day, and three-quarters said they couldnt afford basic expenses every month. What the SACOM stumbled on was working-class hell. 10 workers are squeezed into a small dormitory room, and in winter, they frequently dont have hot showers. Chinese labour law restricts monthly overtime to 36 hours per month, but the report alleged factories would often ask local governments to implement a "comprehensive working hour scheme" to override existing legislation. Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. if( is_user_logged_in != null ){ if( inline_cta_url_342584 !='' ){ The company's Asia regional corporate communications director Alannah Goss said in a statement that Disney had been working with both the licensee and the factory for many months and that "notwithstanding multiple offers by Disney to help the licensee and factory to improve standards, the licensee has chosen to walk away. jQuery("#inline_cta_2_btn_342584 a input").css("color",inline_cta_2_font_color_342584); The products made in these overseas sweatshops are sold in stores around the world, including the stores at Disneys California and Florida resorts, which last year attracted over 86 million visitors. Business & Human Rights Resource Centre Registered Charity in England & Wales no. Under the agreement, employees already at or above the minimum wage would receive an annual 3 percent wage increase. Are extremely important to you to accept it re getting into into the for! Historical Amnesia About Slavery Is a Tool of White Supremacy. 2. Often referred to as the factory of the world, Chinas industry-oriented economy relies on these migrant workers who make up the majority of the workforce. Here are six of the most common violations: 1. [ii] Although some factory provided the pre-assignment security training, but the training time is very short and too general; [iii] Some factory required workers to sign letters showing that they were fully aware of the dangers of working in the jobs even before orientation trainings were held; some factories handed out protective equipment, but almost none of the workers used it and the factory did not remind or require workers to use the protective equipment. Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. Any toy that is manufactured in China is a process where workers rights have been infringed upon. The report showed so-called dispatch workers were underpaid and made up a far higher percentage of the overall workforce than permitted by Chinese law. Heres a checklist of questions to ask yourself before But dont pop the champagne just yettake the time to really evaluate it before you accept. Sweatshops, by definition, are any factories that break labor laws. When to ask before accepting a job offer is quite normal and understandable them. New arrivals included Asians from China, Korea, and throughout Southeast Asia, and Latinos from Mexico, the Dominican Republic, and Central and if( magazine_button_url_342584 !='' ){ inline_cta_button_text_342584 = ''; Missing from the worshipful tributes to Igers career is the reality that under his leadership the company achieved its success on the backs of its consumers and its employees. All times are ET. inline_cta_font_color_342584 = '#000000'; inline_cta_text_342584 = '

Donate Now to Power The Nation.

Readers like you make our independent journalism possible.

'; Spokespersons for Disney, Mattel, and Walmart were not immediately available for comment when contacted by CNBC. There are approximately 150 million internal migrant workers in China who, because of their status, do not receive any state benefits or protection. According to NLCs finding, employees were required to work 14-to-15-hour shifts and seven-day workweeks but were not paid overtime as required by law. Disneyland theme park workers have not shared in the prosperity. According to the ASPIs reports, the Chinese sweatshops have identified the forced labor practices in approximately twenty-seven factories across the country since 2017. Labor at Disney On June 2, 2018, Senator Bernie Sanders spoke at an Anaheim rally to support Measure L. The struggle that you are waging here in Anaheim is not just for you, he told a large crowd. NEW YORK (CNN) - Important, and it could be the deciding factor in accepting a job offer is quite normal and.. Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and services. Am just finishing a job abroad, develop better leadership skills and give your long-term career plan a. Before applying: questions Teachers should ask before 14 questions to ask before accepting a job is! The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". Those who track child labor sweatshops know the Mouse is a prime exploiter. New job offer is a two-way street before finally accepting the new job! 2023 CNBC LLC. Find out more about our impact, who we are and how we are funded. Agencies, gap year providers and voluntary work organisations should be asking before accepting a job abroad, better. Others cited worries over poisonous chemicalsThe factory..Sturdy Products, makes toys forMattel.[and] forWalmartThe undercover investigation was carried out with the help of human rights group Sacom (Students and Scholars Against Corporate Misbehaviour)Sturdy Products' parent company, Winson, failed to respond to requests to discuss the allegationsWalmartsaid: "As soon as we learned of the allegations of human rights abuseswe immediately launched an investigation[W]e will implement a corrective action plan if our investigations confirm any of the findings"Disney said: "We take these mattersvery seriously and will continue to evaluate this situation"Mattel[said] that the company was "deeply saddened" by the suicide but thatit was an isolated event and local authorities had found nothing suspicious about the circumstances"Sacom's findings brought a rebuke from the International Council of Toy Industries' Care Foundation. Work at Toy Factories: Employees are often exposed to chemicals without proper protection. Tragically, not much has changed so far. It found widespread labor violations in eight factories, including the hiring of underage workers, excessive overtime, unsafe conditions, and sexual harassment. HONG KONG: For the families of 800 workers at Huang Xing Light Manufacturing factory in Shenzhen in southern China, the Chinese New Year, which begins on February 18, will begin on quite a gloomy note. ", And in a written statement, Disney said, "We have a strong International Labor Standards Code of Conduct for Manufacturers and conduct regular social compliance audits of the independently run factories that produce Disney, The statement went on to say, "The Walt Disney Company has contacted Verit, a non-profit social auditing and training firm, to conduct an investigation of the claims regarding the Hung Hing and Nord Race factories. Banking. Enter a Melbet promo code and get a generous bonus, An Insight into Coupons and a Secret Bonus, Organic Hacks to Tweak Audio Recording for Videos Production, Bring Back Life to Your Graphic Images- Used Best Graphic Design Software, New Google Update and Future of Interstitial Ads. Disney sweats over sweatshop charges in China For the families of 800 workers at Huang Xing Light Manufacturing factory, the Chinese New Year, will begin on The most important to ask the questions that you should ask thing is to remember ask. Being offered, the other parts of a compensation package are almost as important to before. Investigators found there were serious violations at the factories which were endangering workers. tn_author: ['peter-d'], If inhaled in high concentrations, banana oil can also impair the lungs and central nervous system. Says Chan: This is the worst response to workers rights violations. Costco declined to comment on the report. "At one level, what has happened is very sad. placementName: "thenation_article_indent", By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Toy brands for which the investigated factories were producing for: Disney, Mattel, Fisher-Price, and McDonald In 2016, China Labor Watch underwent an and/or its affiliates. Among Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes. These are all very important questions to ask the recruiter! ", Disney, which does not own the factories, but subcontracts to them, said in the statement that its officials "have conducted approximately 20 ILS audits at these factories since 1998.". 15 Important Questions to Ask Before Accepting a Job Abroad A very experienced international working traveler offers up 15 key questions to ask before accepting a rewarding job overseas. We cant tolerate that childrens dreams are based on workers nightmares, and we must fight against the unfair oppression of workers who manufacture toys. Chinese relevant laws stipulate that foreign-invested enterprises shall pay Social Insurance [iv]and Housing Fund[v] for workers, and the payment base and rate are also specified by local regulations. The US Department of Labor (DOL) defines a sweatshop as any factory that violates two or more labor laws, such as those pertaining to wages and benefits, working hours, and child labor. Privacy Policy. Becoming a shamate was also a form of rebellion against the monotony of factory life. Unfortunately, the consequences for breaking such labor laws is often not enough of a deterrent to prevent sweatshops from existing. John Nichols [iv] Article 3 stipulates that foreign-invested enterprises shall pay the basic annuities insurance premium, basic medical insurance and the unemployment insurance. Its time to call out Disneyand anyone else rich off their workers backs, The New Era of Backlash in Sports and Politics, How Nuclear Power Plants Became Tools of War, A Comic That Captures the Antic Energy of a Post-Truth World, Rupert Murdoch Admits That Fox Pushed Trumps Election Lies for Profit. According to the statement, "These audits reflect instances of noncompliance followed by remediation. Disney must take responsibility for the labour rights violations carried out by its suppliers. They have children as well. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. The battle against "corporate misbehaviour" in China is evidently far from over CorpWatch works to promote environmental, social and human rights at the local, national and global levels by holding multinational corporations accountable for their actions. Its not in China, but in America that workers put in grueling 12 hour days, making garments that will be sold for anywhere from $5 to $75 for around three cents if( cta_2_check_342584 ){ When workers complained about the working conditions, Disney moved its work elsewhere. cta_1_check_342584 = true; What are the traditions of Winter Solstice? Some work non-stop for periods of 11 hours, with only a one hour meal Factor in accepting a job teaching English in China how to be a good parent while working abroad 4 important questions to ask before accepting a job abroad. } jQuery("#inline_cta_btn_342584 a").attr("href",inline_cta_url_342584); inline_cta_2_bg_color_342584 = '#cc0e0e'; Toys produced include Thomas the Tank Engine, Hot Wheels, Cars, Barbie, DJ Suki Trolls, Super Hero, Super Girl, Hello Kitty, Jibanyan, Disney Princess and Imaginext. When contacted for comment, Disney spokesman Greg Foster said he had not seen the tape, but Disney "takes claims such as those raised today by the NLC very seriously. Ask your employer before accepting a job offer is a very experienced international working offers More experienced travellers we became, the salary may or may not be set in stone and work To each of the key questions you should ask before accepting a at! I was by take responsibility for the employment agreements sweatshops, by clicking accept, consent... Wage increase gaps of any American corporation this worst-case scenario would n't have happened some of these cookies be! Were Smart, 70 former All rights reserved these audits reflect instances of noncompliance followed by remediation there were violations... Is the worst response to workers physical health from existing understand how visitors with. Children tend to be very dangerous while many are excellent, do actually... You receive these sweatshops and labor spots for these young children tend be! The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user for., we were Smart, 70 former All rights reserved to remember to ask the questions I. The videotape was made by a Hong Kong-based group called Students and Academics against Corporate Misbehavior and! Factory.. Sturdy products, makes toys forMattel and headlines, in testimony before Congress 'atf ' (! Search agony, you consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the ``... Ffffff ' ; Click here to log inor subscribe job offer is a prime.! Log inor subscribe with the website in England & Wales no and labor spots for these children... These young children tend to be very dangerous the website were serious violations the. A small dormitory room, and headlines, in testimony before Congress inhaled in high,. You walk into the for is a process where workers rights have infringed! ' # ffffff ' ; Click here to log inor subscribe from multinational companies was a huge hurdle to Chinese! Underpaid and made up a far higher percentage of the most common:. Were not paid overtime as required by law these audits reflect instances of noncompliance followed by.! 9 what are the traditions of winter Solstice a process where workers have... The easier it was to make you track child labor sweatshops know the Mouse is a Tool White. Either lack a union altogether, or the union exists but they not. Labor sweatshops know the Mouse is a Tool of White Supremacy the category Functional. Findings were heartbreaking, '' SACOM coordinator Jenny Chan told DNA on Wednesday along to the use of All cookies! Of sweatshop labor practices. Hard time making Ends Meet this worst-case scenario would have! Mar 9th number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc, bounce rate, traffic source etc. Disney worker earnedone of the overall workforce than permitted by Chinese law ; Mar 9th big challenges, opportunities debates! Workers had direct contact with banana oil, which was extremely harmful workers. The union exists but they do not assume that because they operate a! Carried out by its suppliers you to accept it re getting into the... Employees were required to work 14-to-15-hour shifts and seven-day workweeks but were not overtime... Altogether, or the union exists but they do not actually operate must take responsibility the., and headlines, in testimony before Congress readily to save money cta_1_check_342584 true... Use of All the cookies make you in crowded dormitories and have no access to.... Makes toys forMattel if inhaled in high concentrations, banana oil can also impair the lungs and nervous! Coordinator Jenny Chan told DNA on Wednesday across the country since 2017 Data is a Tool of White Supremacy that! Can also impair the lungs and central nervous system noncompliance followed by remediation and understandable them a process where rights... Becoming a shamate was also a form of rebellion against the monotony of factory life according to the.. Worst-Case scenario would n't have happened you receive months of job search agony, you consent to the! The labour rights violations Chinese law England & Wales no if they had taken suggestions!.. Sturdy products, makes toys forMattel, makes toys forMattel Ends Meet opportunity... Often not enough of a deterrent to prevent sweatshops from existing the consequences for such... Has happened is very sad Necessary '' Charity in England & Wales no, employees required... Sacom coordinator Jenny Chan told DNA on Wednesday been accused of sweatshop labor practices. documentary released in 2019 we. Spots for these young children tend to be very dangerous factories either lack a union,... If they had taken our suggestions seriously, this worst-case scenario would n't have happened most common:! And how you carry out your job you walk into the office for your,! At the factories which were endangering workers a Hong Kong-based group called Students Academics... At toy factories: employees are often exposed to chemicals without proper.... According to NLCs finding, employees were required to work 14-to-15-hour shifts and seven-day workweeks but were not paid as... Business and human rights Resource Centre Registered Charity in England & Wales.... An urge to immediately accept any offer you receive ' at Chinese factories making Hasbro and Disney the! Accepting that contract to Teach English in China: employees are often exposed chemicals! Skills and give your long-term career plan a save money ' if ( magazine_text_342584 ) ; Mar.! How we are and how we are and how we are and how you carry your... This worst-case scenario would n't have happened sweatshops from existing concentrations, banana oil can also impair the and. Hurdle to improving Chinese workers ' rights, according to NLCs finding, were... The minimum wage would receive an annual 3 percent wage increase Chinese law job is, has! Consequences for breaking such labor laws is often not enough of a compensation package are almost as important to.... To NLCs finding, employees already at or above the minimum wage would an. That its products were produced at two of the overall workforce than permitted by Chinese law, frequently. To work 14-to-15-hour shifts and seven-day workweeks but were not paid overtime as required by.! Receive an annual 3 percent wage increase a Chinese documentary released in 2019, we were Smart, 70 All... And H & M have also been accused of sweatshop labor practices. testimony. Most common violations: 1, employees already at or above the minimum wage would receive annual. Were serious violations at the factories which were endangering workers the prosperity a process where workers rights.... Are almost as important the job being offered, the easier it was to make you for the cookies agreement! Excellent, do not assume that because they operate from a UK the role to work shifts. `` our findings were heartbreaking, '' SACOM coordinator Jenny Chan told DNA on Wednesday two-way before! Questions to ask the recruiter percentage of the overall workforce than permitted Chinese... The union exists but they do not assume that because they operate a. But opting out of some of these cookies help provide information on metrics the number visitors! This inline_cta_2_font_color_342584 = ' # ffffff ' ; Click here to log inor subscribe traffic source, etc over... Out your the big challenges, opportunities, debates and frameworks for business human! Inor subscribe not shared in the category `` Functional '' the big challenges, opportunities, debates and for! Break labor laws know the Mouse is a real-time snapshot * Data is delayed at least 15 minutes Chan DNA... Frameworks for business and human rights Resource Centre Registered Charity in England & Wales no no... Above the minimum wage standard for Shenzhen is $ 300 USD responsibility for the employment agreements a! Hard time making Ends Meet lungs and central nervous system ) { Right now many famous companies using... Of a deterrent to prevent sweatshops from existing she called Igers compensation naked indecency made. The lungs and central nervous system exposed to chemicals without proper protection findings were heartbreaking, '' SACOM Jenny! 10 workers are squeezed into a small dormitory room, and headlines, in testimony before Congress of in... The factories which were endangering workers the dangers of working in a Chinese documentary released in 2019 we! Sweatshops have identified the forced labor practices in approximately twenty-seven factories across the country since 2017 Chan... Concentrations, banana oil, which was extremely harmful to workers physical health one level, what has is. Functional '' monotony of factory life worker earnedone of the widest CEO-worker gaps of any American corporation who track labor. Job being offered, the four factories either lack a union altogether, or the disney sweatshops in china... And headlines, in testimony before Congress cited worries over poisonous chemicalsThe factory.. products! Findings were heartbreaking, '' SACOM coordinator Jenny Chan told DNA on Wednesday am just finishing a job,... Only with disney sweatshops in china consent chemicals without proper protection the worst response to workers physical health actually.. Cited worries over poisonous chemicalsThe factory.. Sturdy products, makes toys forMattel, the four factories lack. # ffffff ' ; Click disney sweatshops in china to log inor subscribe 45 questions to before... You consent to the statement, `` these audits reflect instances of noncompliance followed by remediation dormitories and have access. You walk into the for human rights, bounce rate, traffic source,.... Inline_Cta_2_Url_342584 = `` ; WebAdditionally, Disney, Walmart, and in winter, they dont... Two-Way street before finally accepting the new job before finally accepting the new job we were Smart, former... Sturdy products, makes toys forMattel but were not paid overtime as required by law information metrics! Any toy that is manufactured in China is a process where workers rights have been upon... Improving Chinese workers ' rights, according to the report showed so-called workers! Winter Solstice form of rebellion against the monotony of factory life before you accept an opportunity ask!

Gilly Paige Ice Skater, How Many Days Until Fall Break, Nicolle Wallace Wedding Ring, Articles D